Skip to content

Pension Calculator

Decide between a lump sum and a monthly pension, or between single-life and joint-and-survivor payouts, using present values.

FinancialUpdated Free · No sign-up

How to use the Pension Calculator

  1. Pick what you want to work out using the tabs: Lump sum vs monthly or Single vs joint survivor.
  2. Enter Lump sum offered.
  3. Enter Monthly pension.
  4. Enter Your age now.
  5. Enter Pension start age.
  6. Enter Life expectancy.
  7. Fill in the remaining fields, or keep their sensible defaults.
  8. Read your answer in the results panel. It updates as you type, and the breakdown, step-by-step working and any charts or tables appear below it.
  9. Use Share link to save or send the exact calculation, or Copy to paste the results elsewhere.

Lump sum or monthly pension?

Many employers let you take your pension as one lump sum instead of monthly payments for life. To compare them fairly, the calculator turns the stream of monthly payments into a single value today, its present value, by discounting each payment at the return you could earn by investing the lump sum yourself.

PV = Σ paymentk ÷ (1 + r/12)k

If the present value of the pension is higher than the lump sum, the pension is the better deal at that discount rate, and the other way round. The calculator also finds the break-even return: the annual return you would need to earn on the lump sum just to match the pension. If you doubt you can reliably beat that return after fees, the pension wins.

Worked example

You are 65 and offered either $250,000 now or $1,500 a month for life. If you expect to live to 85, that’s 240 payments. Discounted at 5% a year, the payments are worth about $227,288 today, so the lump sum is worth about $22,700 more. The break-even return is around 3.9%. If you would keep the money in safe bonds earning 3%, the pension looks better. If you live past 85, the pension gains further.

Single-life vs joint-and-survivor

A single-life pension pays the most each month but stops when you die. A joint-and-survivor pension pays less while you’re alive, then keeps paying your spouse a set share (50%, 75% or 100%) for the rest of their life. The second mode adds up and discounts both options using your and your spouse’s life expectancies. With a $2,000 single-life pension against $1,750 joint with 50% survivor, and the spouse outliving you by five years, single-life pays $480,000 in total and joint pays $472,500.

Things to weigh

  • Longevity: a pension is insurance against living a long time. Good health and long-lived parents favour it.
  • Inflation: most private pensions have no cost-of-living increase, so their real value shrinks every year.
  • Security: in the US, the PBGC insures private pensions up to a limit.
  • Flexibility: a lump sum can be left to heirs and drawn on for emergencies, but it can also run out.

This is an estimate, not financial advice.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to take a pension lump sum or monthly payments?

It depends on your life expectancy, your investing skill and your need for flexibility. If the break-even return is higher than you can realistically earn, or you expect a long life, the monthly pension is usually better value.

What discount rate should I use?

Use the after-fee return you would realistically earn on the lump sum at similar risk. For a guaranteed pension, high-quality bond yields of about 4–5% are a sensible benchmark.

Should I choose a joint-and-survivor pension?

If your spouse depends on your pension and might outlive you, the survivor option protects them. If your spouse has their own good pension or life insurance, single-life may pay more.

Are pension payments taxable?

Usually yes. Pension income is generally taxed as ordinary income, and a lump sum taken as cash is taxed all at once unless you roll it into an IRA.