Skip to content

Rent vs Buy Calculator

Enter the home you would buy and the rent you would pay.

FinancialUpdated Free · No sign-up

How to use the Rent vs Buy Calculator

  1. Enter Home price.
  2. Enter Down payment.
  3. Enter Interest rate.
  4. Enter Loan term.
  5. Enter Buying closing costs.
  6. Fill in the remaining fields, or keep their sensible defaults.
  7. Read your answer in the results panel. It updates as you type, and the breakdown, step-by-step working and any charts or tables appear below it.
  8. Use Share link to save or send the exact calculation, or Copy to paste the results elsewhere.

A fair comparison

Comparing a mortgage payment with rent is misleading. Owners also pay property tax, insurance, maintenance and HOA dues, plus closing costs to buy and commission to sell. Renters, meanwhile, keep the down payment invested. This calculator puts both paths on the same footing by tracking net worth each year.

How the model works

  • At the start, the buyer spends the down payment and closing costs. The renter invests that same amount instead.
  • Each year the buyer pays mortgage, property tax and maintenance (both as a percentage of the current home value), insurance and HOA. The renter pays rent and renter’s insurance.
  • Whoever spends less that year invests the difference at your chosen return, so both sides put in the same money.
  • The home grows at the appreciation rate, rent at the rent increase rate, and insurance and HOA at the cost inflation rate.

Buyer net worth = home value × (1 − selling costs) − loan balance + investments

Renter net worth = investments

The break-even year is the first year in which the buyer’s net worth, after paying to sell, is at least the renter’s.

Worked example

Take a $100,000 home bought outright, with no running costs and no price growth, against renting at $1,000 a month with a 0% return. After 5 years the renter has the $100,000 they never spent. The buyer has the house plus the $60,000 they didn’t pay in rent, so they are $60,000 ahead. With realistic inputs (a $400,000 home, 20% down, 6.5%, $2,200 rent and 3% growth), buying usually wins only after several years, because selling costs and early interest take a lot of the gains.

What matters most

  • Time: the longer you stay, the more buying’s upfront costs are spread out.
  • Price-to-rent ratio: where homes cost more than about 20 times annual rent, renting often wins.
  • Investment return: a high assumed return favours renting, but only if the renter really invests the difference.
  • Appreciation: small changes compound over 10 or more years, so try several values.

The model ignores tax effects such as the mortgage interest deduction, the capital gains exclusion on a main home and tax on investment gains. Treat it as an estimate, not financial advice.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to rent or buy?

It depends on how long you will stay, local prices compared with rents, and what you would earn by investing instead. Buying usually wins over longer periods. Renting often wins if you might move within about five years.

What is the break-even point in rent vs buy?

The year in which the buyer’s net worth, after selling costs and repaying the loan, first matches or beats the renter’s invested savings.

Why does the calculator invest the difference?

To compare fairly, both paths should spend the same total money. Whoever has lower costs in a year invests the savings, as the renter does with the down payment at the start.

What is the 5% rule for renting vs buying?

A shortcut that puts the yearly unrecoverable cost of owning at about 5% of the home value (tax, maintenance and cost of capital). If annual rent is below that, renting may be cheaper. This calculator does the full year-by-year version.